Fluorescent amino acids (FAAs) offer significant advantages over fluorescent proteins in applications where the fluorophore size needs to be limited or minimized. A long-sought goal in biological spectroscopy/microcopy is to develop visible FAAs by modifying the indole ring of tryptophan. Herein, we examine the absorption spectra of a library of 4-substituted indoles and find that the frequency of the absorption maximum correlates linearly with the global electrophilicity index of the substituent. This finding permits us to identify two promising candidates, 4-formyltryptophan (4CHO-Trp) and 4-nitrotryptophan (4NO₂-Trp), both of which can be excited by visible light. Further fluorescence measurements indicate that while 4CHO-indole (and 4CHO-Trp) emits cyan fluorescence with a reasonably large quantum yield (ca. 0.22 in ethanol), 4NO₂-indole is essentially non-fluorescent, suggesting that 4CHO-Trp (4NO₂-Trp) could be useful as a fluorescence reporter (quencher). In addition, we present a simple method for synthesizing 4CHO-Trp.