An investigation of asymmetric total syntheses of three indole-imidazole alkaloids from histidine are described. A common advanced piperidinone was contructed via a ring-closing metathesis which was then subjected to a modified Fischer indole synthesis. Deprotection of an N-tosyl group via a dissolving metal reduction affords haploscleridamine which upon reaction with aqueous formaldehyde in trifluoroethanol provided villagorgin A. On closer examination, it was found that villagorgin A was produced as a byproduct during the reductive detosylation in the presence of magnesium and methanol. Attempts to obtain the brominated haploscleridamine congener, lissoclin C through use of bromophenyl hydrazone were thwarted by reductive debromination during deprotection efforts. Investigation of the enantiopurity of the synthetic natural products revealed production of almost racemic materials in some batches as the result of partial racemization of an early stage intermediate. A revised approach routinely provided scalemic haploscleridamine and villagorgin in 30% ee. Analysis of the enantiomer composition of all intermediates by HPLC using columns with chiral stationary phases; this analysis revealed several steps where erosion of enantiomer composition occurred.