Three lipopeptide analogues of the lantibiotic nisin A have been synthesised on-resin using Fmoc-SPPS techniques to investigate the structure–activity relationship of the A and B ring of these types of lanthipeptides. Lanthionine and methyllanthionine macrocycles were incorporated using orthogonally protected residues for on-resin cyclisation. Unsaturated dehydroalanine and, for the first time, dehydrobutyrine were synthesised on-resin from their cysteine derivatives. However, none of the synthetic or semi-synthetic lipopeptide analogues of nisin showed inhibitory activity towards bacterial strains that are normally sensitive to nisin.