Fire and Materials ( IF 1.979 ) Pub Date : 2022-11-22 , DOI:
10.1002/fam.3119
BirgitÖstman
The international standard ISO 5660 Cone Calorimeter test is widely used in fire research and for modeling, but not so often in legislation or requirements on products. The available acceptance criteria for products in different countries and codes have therefore been compiled and are presented in tables. Some research studies have also been included.
There are several national standards with different designation based on ISO 5660 for fire testing according to the Cone Calorimeter, for example, ASTM E1354 in the US, AS/NZS 3837 in Australia, and New Zealand.
ISO 5660 Reaction-to-fire is a small-scale test method and contains four parts:
Heat release, smoke production, and mass loss rate
Smoke production rate (dynamic measurement)
Guidance on measurement
Measurement of heat release for determination of low levels of combustibility
Part 1 is most used and heat exposure at 50 kW/m2 is preferred in research and for expressing acceptance criteria, see Table 1. In a few cases, heat exposure at 25 kW/m2 is utilized, see Table 2. Part 4 uses a larger cone heater and allows larger specimens 150 × 150 mm compared to 100 × 100 mm for the other parts. National versions of ISO 5660-4 are used in Canada as CAN/ULC-S135 and in the US as ASTM E2965.
TABLE 1. Acceptance criteria according to the Cone Calorimeter (ISO 5660-1 or equivalent test methods) at 50 kW/m2 used in codes and national regulations
Country/Code
Weathering method
Acceptance criteria
Used for
Time to ignition, s
Max HRR peak, kW/m2
Max HRR average, kW/m2
Max THR, MJ/m2
Test time, min, min
Europe
EN 16755
-
-
150 (30 s average)
20% increase compared to before weathering
10 min after ignition
Fire retardant wood products
Japan
-
-
200
-
8
20
Non-combustible products
Japan
-
-
200
-
8
10
Quasi Non-combustible products
Japan
-
-
200
-
8
5
Fire retardant products
Korea
-
-
200 (except for 20% of thickness)
Semi Non-combustible products
Korea
-
-
200 (except for 20% of thickness)
Fire retardant products
IBC International Building Code
-
-
150
-
20
-
Water resistive barriers
IBC International Building Code
-
-
400
-
-
-
Children´s play structures
IFC International Fire Code
-
-
300
-
-
-
Waste containers and similar
NFPA 1 Fire Code
-
-
300
-
-
-
Plastic rubbish containers
NFPA 101 Life Safety Code
-
-
300
-
-
-
Plastic rubbish containers
NFPA 5000 Building Code
-
-
150
-
20
-
Water resistive barriers
New Zealand
-
-
150
-
-
External cladding B
New Zealand
ASTM D2898 modif.
-
100
-
25
15
Fire retardant timber cladding
IMO FTP (MSC 88/26/Add.2
-
> 20
-
< 60 (30 s average)
< 20
20
Material for furniture and other components
MiL-STD-2031
-
< 65
< 50 (30 s average)
Composite materials used in US Navy
Australia
-
Indices based on Kokkala et al. Fire and Materials12
Wall and ceiling linings
TABLE 2. Acceptance criteria according to the Cone Calorimeter (ISO 5660-1 or equivalent test methods) at 25 kW/m2 used in codes and national regulations
Country
Weathering method
Acceptance criteria
Used for
Max HRR peak, kW/m2
Max THR, MJ/m2
Test time, min
New Zealand
-
100
-
15
External cladding A
Australia
ASTM D2898 modif.
100
60 (10 min after ignition)
10 min after ignition
Bushfire resisting timber
A separate standard on mass loss rate is also available as ISO 17554. It may be used for industry production control.
Acceptance criteria for general classification of building products are used in New Zealand as direct test data, see Table 1. Australia uses indices based on Cone Calorimeter data, and direct test data only for Bushfire resisting timber, see Table 2. The codes IBC and IFC use acceptance criteria for special products like water resistive barriers, children's playground structures, and plastic rubbish containers. The same is true for the NFPA standards 1, 101 and 5000.
In the European standard EN 16755 and in New Zealand, the Cone Calorimeter is used specifically for fire retardant treated wood products before and after weathering, see Table 1.
The main parameter used in acceptance criteria is peak heat release rate (HRR) in kW/m2. For non-combustibility total heat release (THR) in MJ/m2 is added in Japan and Korea. Canada and NFPA 220 use THR for non-combustibility but measured at different heat exposures and slightly different cone heaters, see Table 3.
TABLE 3. Acceptance criteria according to the Cone Calorimeter (ISO 5660-4 or equivalent test methods) at 50 or 75 kW/m2 for non-combustible products
Country/Code
Acceptance criteria
Test standard
Comments
Heat exposure, kW/m2
Max HRR peak, kW/m2
Max THR, MJ/m2
Test time, min
Canada
-
3
Until no heat or smoke release
CAN/ULC-S135
Same cone heater size as ISO 5660-1
50
NFPA 220 Types of construction
150 (except for <10 s)
8
20
ASTM E2965
Larger cone heater size than ISO 5660-1
75
Table 4 presents two research studies with the aim to determine acceptance criteria based on extensive fire testing. The study by Wade aimed at creating performance-based criteria and is used as background verification for the legislation in New Zealand and the one by Tsantaridis et al focused on wood products.
TABLE 4. Suggested acceptance criteria according to the Cone Calorimeter (ISO 5660-1 or equivalent test methods) at 50 kW/m2 from research studies
Paper
Time to ignition, s
Acceptance criteria
Applicable to
Max HRR peak, kW/m2
Max THR, MJ/m2
Test time, min
Tsantaridis et al., Interflam 2010
≥40
≤100 (for ≥900 s from start of heat exposure)
-
Fire retardant wood products
Euroclass B
Tsantaridis et al., Interflam 2010
≥30
≤180 (for ≥900 s from start of heat exposure)
-
Fire retardant wood products
Euroclass C
Tsantaridis et al., Interflam 2010
≥15
≤250 (for ≥900 s from start of heat exposure)
-
Wood products
Euroclass D
13
-
150
-
15
External claddings